Heart Palpitations Forum

Heart Palpitations Forum
http://palps.chemicalforums.com/cgi-bin/YaBB.pl
Heart Palpitations Forum >> Symptoms and other concerns >> Question
http://palps.chemicalforums.com/cgi-bin/YaBB.pl?num=1293906398

Message started by boringdanielle on Jan 1^st, 2011, 10:26am

Title: Question
Post by boringdanielle on Jan 1^st, 2011, 10:26am

Ok,here is a question. How come all of the literature I read says if the ectopics last for more than a few minutes, they could be dangerous, yet I read all the time when people have had them for hours or days. I don't get it. How to know when your ectopics are dangerous or not? Currently I am wearing a holter monitor and hopefully it will clear up some information for me. Just some unclarity. This is all new to me and my ectopics at times seem to cause me panic attacks. I worry than the ectopics are something wrong that is why it sends me into a panic attack also. Sometimes I have the ectopics and they don't bother. I am so confused. :-/

Happy New Year Everyone!! ;D

Title: Re: Question
Post by RLR on Jan 2^nd, 2011, 2:59pm

Okay, this is a common misconception and inaccurate association is being drawn between benign palpitations as a consequence of vagus nerve stimulation and alternatively clinical arrhythmias such as atrial fibrillation. The events you and others here are experiencing are not universal by any means, but indeed that is what you are suggesting.

Understand that there are a tremendous number of pathological arrhythmias and it is these events for which the literature is drafted, more especially to a medically trained audience. You can't simply peruse over this type of literature on the internet and derive some type of common sense association between the discussion points and your own symptoms. If it were in any way that simplistic, I and countless other physicians would have been able to avoid years of education and training.

Benign palpitations constitutes a diagnosis of exclusion, meaning that when we evaluate you using diagnostic equipment, we are searching for the presence of all factors known to represent risk. If they are absent, then the absolute only other cause for the palpitations is one that is benign in origin.

Patients commonly ask the question "But how on earth do I know whether the next ones I experience are harmless? I've had some that are different than the ones I normally experience. It's those that frighten me so much."

The kind of underlying pathology which produces arrhythmias which are of concern and risk cannot simply appear like throwing a switch, the elements of which actually take many years to develop. In other words, you don't experience benign palpitations associated with anxiety and stress one day and suddenly have pathological arrhythmias the next. That is a presumptive possibility created entirely in the minds of patients due to a lack of the requisite background and training in medicine.

You'll be fine. While you may indeed experience variation in the palpitations, it in no way suggests they are suddenly composed of a pathological type that could place you at risk. It absolutely does not work in such a fashion. Again, irrational fear produces this unrealistic potential.

Best regards,

Rutheford Rane, MD (ret.)