Welcome, Guest. Please Login
YaBB - Yet another Bulletin Board
  News:
  HomeHelpSearchLogin  
 
Pages: 1
Send Topic Print
RLR what do you think? (Read 10667 times)
skipabeat
Junior Member
**
Offline

I Love YaBB 2!

Posts: 27

RLR what do you think?
Feb 08th, 2013, 11:09am
 
Hello RLR, I know you have helped many people on this forum, and you have a lot of knowledge about the vagus nerve and palpitations. So I am writing to you because I had a bad episode of palpitations last night, that lasted for hours on end. Through my dinner and right into the early morning hours. I've been fine for weeks. With no anxiety, and only a few palps here and there. I know that you mention the vagus nerve over and over. I've been to 3 cardiologists and many regular MD's. Nothing was ever found. I was always told they are common and harmless. These doctors prescribed beta blockers, which didn't help me at all. So, I don't take them. I've been to a therapist who says it's not the vagus nerve, She wants to treat me with anti-anxiety medicines. But, you claim it's the vagus nerve. I'm so frustrated with all of the diagnoses. While there still is nothing that slows or stops the episode while it's happening. What I really want to know is how can I at least slow the palpitations down, while I'm having an 8 hour episode? I really wish I could stop it, but slowing them down would be good. The calming thing that eveyone talks about, you know, the try to relax and breathe through your nose and so on, just doesn't work for me. In all of your posts, I have never seeen you mention sedatives. Is there any solution to this madness? Not one person has been able to help me so far. I've been to so many doctors. They all say that nothing is wrong. I'm FED UP. Thanks for your time and help with this matter. A quick note. I've been getting these palpitations since I was in my early 20's. They didn't seem to bother me then. But now that I am 58 I am extremely nervous about it. I would also like to mention that my blood pressure is 117/75 and my heart rate is between 62 and 70. Again, thank you for your help RLR, I hope this doesn't offend you in anyway. I'm reaching out to you because I know your knowledgeable in this field.  So, my main question is, Is there anything I can take while it's happening, to slow it down or stop it? That way my mind can relax. My mind will not relax, until the palpitations stop. I don't know why, but that's just the way I am. Thank You very much again.  Sad
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
skipabeat
Junior Member
**
Offline

I Love YaBB 2!

Posts: 27

Re: RLR what do you think?
Reply #1 - Feb 15th, 2013, 4:49pm
 
ttt
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
saab
Senior Member
****
Offline



Posts: 233

Re: RLR what do you think?
Reply #2 - Feb 16th, 2013, 2:30pm
 
Just saw your post wanted to respond. I am not sure I have ever read of anything that can promptly stop a bout of pvc's, I am afraid.  What I have found most useful is to sit down and do some cognitive therapy written exercises to deal with the huge surge of anxiety that they bring. I also read my cog therapy books and listen to my mindfulness cd's which help to relax me.

The Anxiety Network website has some good info, as does No More Panic. I have found the following books very helpful:

Self Help for Your Nerves - Dr Claire Weekes
Stop Thinking Start Living - Richard Carlson
Phobia and Anxiety Workbook - Bourne and co.
Mindfulness Way Through Depression (with cd) - Jon Kabbat Zinn and co.

Hope this helps.
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
sto12
Junior Member
**
Offline

Heart Palpitations
Forum

Posts: 21

Re: RLR what do you think?
Reply #3 - Feb 16th, 2013, 7:20pm
 
Palpitations are my latest obsession and have been for the last 3 or 4 weeks. I am at my doctors every other day because of them. I ended up in the ER a few weeks ago with an elevated heart rate and sky high blood pressure. The ER doctor insisted I take two Valium which I refused. Then he said "if you want the blood pressure to go down take the Valium" so I did and my heart rate and blood pressure returned to normal within an hour. An ECG showed normal sinus rhythm and blood tests were all normal. Anxiety was the diagnosis. Of course it didn't end there, hence the now regular visits to my doctor. Or should I say the now regular visits for palpitations because before that I was a regular visitor for a never ending list of ailments. Last week my doctor told me to find the pulse in my neck and put my finger on it for 2 minutes and the palpitations would stop. I tried it and sometimes it works. I suspect that he suggested it because he figured it would distract me from the palpitations long enough for them to stop. I should probably also mention that it was on that day that he wrote the referral to the psychiatrist. My first appointment is in March. I guess that I have at least stopped focusing on every other area of my body. That is if you discount Friday. On Thursday night I developed an ulcer on my tongue and turned up at the doctors on Friday worried that I had tongue cancer. The mind is a powerful thing and mine has got the better of me. Can I just say that I am a school teacher but I also have a degree in Psychology. It has not helped me one little bit. If self-analysis is possible then I don't have the knack for it. Until the ER incident I would have said "don't take the sedatives" but I have been taking them for the last 3 weeks. Only if I am feeling particularly anxious. So sometimes only 1 each day. I want to take none at all and I want to stop having to take blood pressure medication. So I know I need to get on top of the anxiety. I don't know how RLR feels about sedatives but I would be interested to read what he has to say. Good luck, I hope you feel better soon. Smiley
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
skipabeat
Junior Member
**
Offline

I Love YaBB 2!

Posts: 27

Re: RLR what do you think?
Reply #4 - Mar 5th, 2013, 6:13pm
 
ttt
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
RLR
YaBB Administrator
*****
Offline

Retired Physician

Posts: 2057

Gender: male
Re: RLR what do you think?
Reply #5 - Mar 7th, 2013, 8:17pm
 
Okay, I've read your posting and concerns. There are several points to be discussed here. Firstly, we need to draw attention to the underlying concern which is fueling your apprehension in contrast to the actual circumstances. Virtually all persons who experience palpitations of this type become overwhelmingly concerned that the events hold the capacity to induce a cardiac event or transform into some type of dangerous arrhythmia that is very unpredictably placing their very life in danger.

Frustration is quite common and is largely manifested by repeated failure of the medical community to singularly define and resolve the symptoms, the nature of which impose the aforementioned risk to such a proximal extent. In other words, patients feel helpless in the presence of imminent risk while the medical community seems unconcerned and ambiguous regarding the need to resolve the symptoms and restore a sense of safety to the mind of the patient.

The use of beta-blockers in the context of arresting palpitation events is considered off-label. Although beta-blocker therapy can reduce cardiac force and augment regulation of heart rhythm, the drug demonstrates no efficacy, or effect, upon factors which cause vagus nerve-induced palpitation events to occur. Any brief respite experienced in such cases is universally due to common placebo effects. It is of importance, however, that the same force which produces placebo effect is also capable of actually reducing the incidence of the palpitation events within the same time-frame. The inability of the drug to impart positive influence is due to the mere fact that the palpitations in such instances are extra-cardiac in nature, meaning that they arise from outside the heart.

It's also important to note here that the premise of frustration toward your condition and the medical community is to a large extent manifested due to your rather firm perceptions that the underlying cause is due to an underlying organic, or physical, problem. It is natural to presume that physical symptoms constitute a direct relationship to underlying physical cause, but in fact this is actually not the case at all. Additionally, the perception that physiological sensations constitute physical symptoms is actually in question as well.

The discussion of these points is not to suggest that "it's all in your head" by any means, but rather to point out that perception of what is causing your physical symptoms versus the actual cause is partly to blame for your frustration. Since your heart is the source of the symptom, then it only seems logical to pursue evaluation and consult by a cardiologist or similar specialist. Despite the fact that most all tests by patients using this approach result in negative evidence for underlying physical disease or causal factors, patients are nevertheless compelled to stay the course because their symptoms will not abate.

So we have several elements here to entertain when attempting to draw reference to underlying cause for your symptoms. It's important to focus upon facts within your posting which can offer direction. You've been to three cardiologists and many regular MDs and yet nothing was ever found. If we examine this premise, logic forces recognition of the fact that regardless of how many physicians and specialists evaluate the symptoms, no underlying organic cause can be found. Again, this is not to say that the symptoms are not physical or real, but merely that the underlying cause is not based in organic pathology. All diagnostic test equipment is patterned by algorithms based upon real disease and if test patterns from the patient do not match the algorithms, then no disease is present. This is a medical fact rather than presumption.

The core of the problem here is that you believe yourself to be at imminent risk at some point due to the presence of the palpitations and feel compelled to continue searching for the cause to obtain both resolution and a return to a life where you feel safe once again. It is at this juncture you must bring to question whether you are actually at any risk at all and whether your concept of what the palpitation events represent is accurate to any degree. Until you successfully resolve this contradiction, the patterns being demonstrated will continue. You are frustrated by all the diagnoses because you are seeking the answer based upon your own interpretation of the underlying cause.

In answer to your question, there is no magic pill which will abate or diminish palpitation events of this type directly. They are a manifestation of an internal climate of stress and anxiety. Also understand that the anxiety or stress itself does not produce the events, but rather that the events are produced secondary to changes in the central nervous system which are caused by the stress and anxiety. Your concerns are growing because you feel that at your age, the risk of harm is now more imminent. Again, you must come to question whether your interpretation of the problem and the consequences is accurate. Careful reflection of all that has transpired can provide a great deal of insight and subsequent reduction in symptoms. Here are some facts that will help point you in the right direction.

Age has absolutely nothing to do with whether palpitations of the type you are experiencing pose greater risk. I'll share with you here that throughout medical history, there has never been a single recorded case of a patient suffering any harm whatsoever from the type of palpitation events you are experiencing. Not a single case. I'm now 93 years of age and most of my patients grew old with me and under my care, many of which experienced the very same palpitation events you experience. Not a single one of those patients ever came to harm or expired prematurely as a result of the palpitations. The events cannot wear out your heart, causes any type of cardiac event to ensue or even produce some type of dangerous arrhythmia. Such a premise is rooted in your interpretation of their potential, not the actual facts.

"I've been to so many doctors. They all say that nothing is wrong. I'm FED UP."

I highlighted this comment merely to offer insight regarding the premise under discussion and a source of the persistent conflict. Your statement reveals that you are frustrated because your doctors are unable to find the cause that you believe to be present. Consequently, the perception is that your physicians demonstrate contradiction and incompetency. In other words, you have adopted a sense of increasing risk associated with the palpitations with respect to advancing age and despite the passage of time and increasing risk, your doctors are unable to find the underlying cause.

"That way my mind can relax. My mind will not relax, until the palpitations stop. I don't know why, but that's just the way I am."

I also wanted to highlight this comment because it is extremely common among persons experiencing symptoms similar to your own and actually constitutes an ultimatum. In other words, you refuse to relax and accept the facts until your symptoms abate. This is a very important because you need to realize that your state of mind with respect to the apprehension being generated is driving the forces which produce the symptoms. Your mind won't relax because you are rigidly adhered to your perceptions rather than the facts.

You are in no danger, regardless of how old you become, as a consequence of the presence of the palpitation events. The key to change is exchanging irrational fears for logic and medical facts. It's important to realize that the "way you are" has a lot to do with the presence and persistence of your symptoms. There is nothing medically wrong with you.

Best regards,

Rutheford Rane, MD (ret.)




Back to top
 
 

Best Regards and Good Health
  IP Logged
bayroot
Full Member
***
Offline

Heart Palpitations
Forum

Posts: 57

Gender: male
Re: RLR what do you think?
Reply #6 - Mar 8th, 2013, 12:44am
 
This post by rlr reminded me of something we used to do in university. It might be an analogy that helps what rlr is saying.

I lived in dorms and we had metal locks on the doors which were opened by a keycard. As a prank, when somebody would be on the way back to coming into their room we used to get some water (from a pistol or glass) and splash their lock. The water hitting the lock would disable it for a short period so that you could not access the room. the person would ask us about it, to which we would pretend that we knew nothing about it. Eventually they would call security to come and help, at which time it would be back to normal again and they would look stupid.

It seems like the person was thinking the problem was the lock that was malfunctioning, and they always thought the door had a problem. they had no idea that the door was fine, it was just a temporary disturbance caused by water from us that was making it temporarily react.
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
richie
Senior Member
****
Offline

I Love YaBB 2!

Posts: 204

Re: RLR what do you think?
Reply #7 - Mar 8th, 2013, 3:06am
 
nice one bayroot.

offcourse Skipabout is anxious about his sensations.
And because he is anxious, and he has skipped beats its anxiety.
But somewhere down the line it started somewhere. And he described he wasnt anxious back then.
So everybody understands if you are anxious of symptoms you have anxiety and that maybe due to changes in nervous system due to the anxiety arousal you maybe get (more) sensations.

But where did it start?
why?
As for all I know I never was anxious BEFORE my sensations started.
So where did it begin?

I quess thats whats puzzling people.
Also the different diagnosis you get. Although no one find anything SERIOUS. which doesnt mean there isnt something wrong and causing this. the explanation you get is mostly different. and they are all well educated medical professionals.

Like I always say.. some think I do have a neurological issue, some dont. They all are experts.
And offcourse people do make mistakes. doctors too.
So that issue is always there if you have a tendency to be occupied with your heatlh or symptoms.

I still believe that explanation is the key !!
Not the explanation. Everything is ok , I cant find a problem, maybe anxiety. No whats causing this, and why isnt it..this or that disease. what can you do about your symptoms? explain !

Why does one man get a heart attack although everything seemd fine a year ago. and is everything ok in me?
Why is tingling and numbness a neurological symptom in many feared neurological problems.. but why when I or someone else has it it is without even an MRI or anything, it's not a problem?

Asking for  answers is considered hypochondric i quess. If person A says.. its ok.. than you have to accept that. But in these times with internet and all diseases flying around you , and you hear of everything in a sec, we need another approach. Tims are changing. People know and question more due that everything is available to us . In my book its a fair question which can help you to get you on your way to a better understanding and dealing with your problems.

And please dont take this the wrong way. When I am 93 I will look back to things with probably more calm , but I very well would like to get to my 90;s too. and fact too. not many people get there.
But I do miss the simple fact that sometimes things are wrong even though people thought it was not. people do get sick. and develop many illnesses. So better safe than sorry.

offcourse living in fear is no option. But its not strange that people reflect to a period they didnt had these symptoms and think , what the hack went wrong? I didnt used to have this, so what changed?

I accept anxiety as a problem. and a not helping one. but its not always the cause but just as mucht times  the effect . the effect itself is not helping the cause.
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
skipabeat
Junior Member
**
Offline

I Love YaBB 2!

Posts: 27

Re: RLR what do you think?
Reply #8 - Mar 10th, 2013, 2:42pm
 
Dear Dr. Rane, Thank You so much for your time and explanations regarding my palpitations. I found your knowledge and your response to my situation extremely helpful, and very comforting. I truly appreciate your time and energy. It means a lot to me and I realize that if I change my way of thinking about it, that I will feel better eventually. It is very helpful to me knowing that I am in no danger at all. Even though all of my doctors and cardiologists have told me this before, I let my fear get the better of me. Now, I realize that my thinking that something was very wrong, is what was making me so much more nervous, and adding to the problem, but it is hard to breake. I am doing my best to relax, I realize that worrying just causes more stress, and more anxiety. Thank You Very Much.
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
Pages: 1
Send Topic Print